corruption Crime Elkhart Indiana Justice Movies police police brutality

Nearly all the officers in charge of an Indiana Police Department have been disciplined – including the chief who keeps promoting them

The new global tinderbox - NationofChange

When Ed Windbigler turned Elkhart’s police chief in January 2016, one in every of his first duties was choosing his prime command employees.

For assistant chief, his second in command, Windbigler named Todd Thayer. Lower than three years earlier than, Thayer had been demoted two ranks for making flippant feedback a few deadly capturing. Witnesses reported he stated a fellow officer might now verify capturing an individual off his “bucket record.”

For patrol captain, Windbigler named Brent Lengthy. Lower than two years earlier than, Lengthy had acquired a four-day suspension for sending inappropriate emails to fellow officers. One e-mail included ugly pictures of a person in one other metropolis who, whereas operating from police, jumped or fell from an overpass and was decapitated on a wrought-iron fence.

Beneath Windbigler, Thayer and Lengthy usually are not aberrations, based on a assessment of personnel information by the South Bend Tribune and ProPublica. Twenty-eight of the Elkhart Police Division’s 34 supervisors, from chief right down to sergeant, have disciplinary data. The explanations vary from carelessness to incompetence to critical, even legal, misconduct. Fifteen of them have served suspensions, together with Windbigler himself, who was as soon as suspended for 3 days – and ordered to pay punitive damages in a federal lawsuit alleging extreme pressure.

One officer promoted to sergeant by Windbigler has been disciplined greater than two dozen occasions, as soon as for utilizing police communications gear to seek advice from “white energy.” One other sergeant choked a person in custody. One other did not report home violence by a fellow officer, who had battered a lady and shot her cat. Nonetheless one other habitually skipped obligatory coaching after which lied about why, saying he had been attending to police union enterprise.

At the very least three present supervisors have been convicted of crimes throughout their careers.

Seven have opened hearth in no less than one deadly capturing. One officer made sergeant by Windbigler fired his gun in three deadly shootings in a bit greater than 4 years, together with one which led to a lawsuit and settlement. One other used his Taser on a highschool scholar whereas working as a useful resource officer, then, every week later, shot and killed a person who turned out to be unarmed.

“That’s excessive. That’s excessive,” stated Walter Signorelli, a lecturer on the John Jay School of Felony Justice, of the variety of deadly shootings by Elkhart police. Signorelli labored over 30 years for the New York Metropolis Police Division earlier than retiring as inspector. “I don’t know what sort of place this Elkhart is.”

From 2013 to 2017, Elkhart police shot and killed six individuals whereas New York Metropolis police killed 43. Elkhart’s inhabitants is 53,000 – New York Metropolis’s, eight.6 million. The NYPD had about seven occasions extra police shootings – in a metropolis with greater than 160 occasions the individuals.

Windbigler and Thayer declined remark by way of the division’s spokesman. Lengthy didn’t reply to interview requests. The Tribune and ProPublica offered the Police Division with their findings; a spokesman stated there can be no response.

On Thursday, Elkhart Mayor Tim Neese referred to as for a “full investigation” of the town’s Police Division to be carried out by the Indiana State Police. “Neese is worried with all people’ civil rights and feels this investigation is important to upholding transparency and sustaining public belief,” a press launch from his workplace stated.

Neese made the request every week after a reporter knowledgeable him of the findings of the Tribune’s and ProPublica’s investigation. Final week, throughout an interview about police supervisors’ disciplinary data, Neese stated, “Clearly cops, by advantage of their career, they’re going to come across individuals underneath very distinctive circumstances … so there are going to be complaints levied towards cops when, the truth is, they’re doing their job.”

When Elkhart makes the nationwide information, it tends to be for its business, not its police drive. Referred to as the “RV Capital of the World,” Elkhart turned a political stage for the nation’s final two presidents. It was one of many first cities Barack Obama visited in his first time period. He handed by way of once more in 2016 to tout the nation’s financial rebound. Donald Trump visited in Might to say, “America is revered once more.”

Nicely earlier than Windbigler turned chief, the Elkhart Police Division allowed officers with disturbing data to remain on the drive, climb the ranks or transfer on to different regulation enforcement jobs. A 1994 research, commissioned by the town, cited the division’s “fame for brutality” and its failure to rein in officers who had “abused residents, violated civil rights, [and] alienated segments of the group.”

The Tribune and ProPublica lately chronicled the Police Division’s flawed investigation of a 1996 capturing during which two males, Keith Cooper and Christopher Parish, have been wrongly convicted. The lead detective in that case remained an investigator regardless of a prolonged document of misconduct – and, upon retirement, acquired letters of advice from high-ranking Elkhart officers, serving to him get employed by a close-by sheriff’s division.

Underneath Windbigler, the Elkhart Police Division seems to have scaled again self-discipline in contrast together with his instant predecessors. On the similar time, civilian oversight has been diminished relatively than strengthened.

Ed Windbigler, Elkhart Police Chief


This month, the town stated two Elkhart cops can be charged with misdemeanor battery after the Tribune requested video that confirmed them repeatedly punching a handcuffed man within the face. Windbigler had beforehand opted to restrict the 2 officers’ self-discipline to reprimands. He advised the oversight board they “simply went slightly overboard once they took him to the bottom,” whereas making no point out of the punches thrown. The mayor has since stated that in hindsight, extra critical self-discipline was in all probability warranted.

Windbigler was made police chief by Neese when he turned mayor in 2016. Neese has a son on the drive – one of many 28 supervisors with disciplinary data – and campaigned on doing extra to help the police. He promised to shift disciplinary oversight from a Public Security Board, with all 5 members appointed by the mayor, to a Police Benefit Fee, with two members chosen by officers. Neese acquired the endorsement of the Fraternal Order of Police, and, after taking workplace, delivered on his promise.

Within the 10 years earlier than Windbigler took over, three prior police chiefs introduced a mean of 20 disciplinary instances a yr to the division’s oversight board.

In Windbigler’s first yr, 2016, he didn’t deliver ahead a single case.

On the finish of 2016, members of the Police Division voted for officer of the yr. The consideration is historically reserved for somebody from the rank and file, not an administrator.

However that yr was an exception.

Officers voted overwhelmingly for Windbigler.


1 / 4 century in the past, Elkhart confronted a string of civil rights lawsuits by which former officers stated that they had witnessed cover-ups and policing gone awry. One stated police would rush right into a low-income condominium complicated to make individuals scatter, then chase whoever ran.

In 1993, a jury in federal courtroom returned judgments towards 5 Elkhart officers accused of violating the rights of two black males.

One plaintiff, Robert Tiggs, stated that in 1989 he was leaving a membership by way of a slender vestibule when he ran into Windbigler, a patrolman on the time. As he tried to slip previous, Windbigler pushed him, Tiggs stated. One other police officer then sprayed Tiggs with mace, after which he was hit, choked and referred to as a racial slur, Tiggs stated.

Windbigler stated that Tiggs raised his voice after they bumped into one another, and that Tiggs pushed him together with his finger and was “very belligerent and mouthy.” Tiggs was being disorderly, Windbigler stated. Requested what constituted disorderly conduct, Windbigler testified, “Increase your voice to the extent the place different individuals take note of you.”

The jury discovered towards Windbigler, ordering him to pay $5,000 in punitive damages. Afterward, he was suspended for 3 days. The Public Security Board wrote to him, “You lacked a degree of tolerance and self-control so necessary to those that achieve your chosen profession.”

Within the lawsuit, parts of the Police Division’s grievance logs from the late ’80s and early ’90s have been disclosed. They confirmed that in a single 16-month interval, Windbigler was named in seven complaints along with the one filed by Tiggs. 5 alleged brutality or battery. In a single, a 28-year-old man stated he was “arrested for no good cause, that he was crushed and his glasses have been damaged.” The personnel file for Windbigler, offered by the town, doesn’t present him being disciplined in any of those different instances.

The opposite plaintiff within the 1993 trial, Demetrius Pegues, alleged that Elkhart’s Police Division was “uncontrolled” and coated up misconduct.

Pegues accused Elkhart police officer Steve Ambrose of punching and choking him throughout an arrest; then beating him in a small room on the police station; then beating him once more within the hospital emergency room whereas Pegues was handcuffed to a mattress. Ambrose denied beating Pegues at any of these occasions.

On the trial, three former cops testified to seeing Ambrose or his companion putting individuals within the metropolis jail or hospital, or each. One stated she knowledgeable a fellow officer, “and I used to be informed to maintain my mouth shut or I’d get fired.” A lady who had been a hospital secretary and nurse’s aide testified that she noticed Ambrose and his companion beating prisoners within the emergency room. Pegues’ lawyer requested what number of occasions. “We’re taking a look at over 20-plus,” the witness answered. (She additionally testified to seeing Windbigler strike a prisoner within the ER. Windbigler, subsequently referred to as to the stand, testified that he had “by no means seen anyone touched” on the hospital by a police officer.)

The jury discovered towards Ambrose, ordering him to pay $50,000 in punitive damages. The Police Division suspended him for 5 days. However Ambrose stored his job.

After the verdicts, Elkhart commissioned a research of its Police Division. Co-authored by a former New York Metropolis police commissioner, that research was launched in 1994. It discovered that Elkhart’s current historical past was marked by an exceedingly excessive variety of brutality complaints, coupled with a scarcity of accountability.

Some Elkhart officers have been pleased with the division’s status for being “liberal with the stick,” the research stated. As well as, the Fraternal Order of Police – its president in 1994 was Bruce Davidson, an officer who later turned a serial financial institution robber and is now in federal jail – bristled at civilian oversight. The FOP “has repeatedly complained that the Chief doesn’t present management as a result of he’s a ‘puppet’ of the Mayor,” the report stated.

Visitors in downtown Elkhart, Indiana. The town is understood nationally as the middle of the RV business and is a marketing campaign prop in presidential politics. (Robert Franklin/South Bend Tribune)


However the report’s authors stated that view of a metropolis’s management was basically incorrect. The mayor, who’s elected, appoints the chief and is answerable for each officer: “Civilian management of the army and police is completely vital in a free society. With out it, the traits of a police state inevitably seem.”

In 1995, the yr after the report was launched, Ambrose shot and killed Derrick Conner, a 22-year-old black man, throughout a chase on foot. Ambrose stated he fired in self-defense. Conner’s household maintained that Conner was unarmed, and filed go well with.

Ambrose was deposed within the spring of 1997.

“Have you ever ever referred to blacks as niggers?” a lawyer requested Ambrose.

“Sure,” Ambrose stated.

Requested if he had used the phrase whereas working, Ambrose stated sure. Requested if different white officers used the phrase, Ambrose stated sure. Greater than as soon as? “Sure.” By multiple officer? “Sure.”

The town elected to not go to trial. The lawsuit was settled for $400,000.

Makes an attempt to succeed in Ambrose by telephone and in writing have been unsuccessful.

Lately, the town’s oversight of police has once more develop into a problem.

Final yr, when the town decreased the mayor’s position in police oversight, Windbigler supported the change, saying he had seen “vindictiveness” towards police from previous mayors.

However Elkhart’s newer historical past challenges the notion that the police have been subjected to unduly harsh oversight.

In a 2011 assembly, the Board of Public Security’s chairwoman, Jean Barton, questioned whether or not the Police Division had correctly notified the board about an officer accused of groping ladies and different sexual misconduct.

She subsequently resigned when Mayor Dick Moore criticized her for conducting the assembly in what he referred to as “a lower than skilled method,” in line with The Elkhart Fact.

Reporters just lately listened to a recording of that assembly: Barton requested direct questions of the chief and a metropolis lawyer, however nothing extra. “Within the assembly I simply repeated the identical query 3 times,” Barton stated in an interview. “The lawyer and the chief of police went to the mayor and stated I used to be impolite.”

‘A studying expertise’

Sergeants are essential first-line supervisors typically known as a police division’s spine. Elkhart’s 19 sergeants embrace Scott Garvey and Jack Oldroyd, two officers who, mixed, have been suspended for nearly 100 days.

Employed in 2001, Garvey was reprimanded or suspended 3 times in his first yr, his probationary interval.

After “being advised quite a few occasions to not” use police communications gear for something however law-enforcement functions, Garvey “blatantly violated” the prohibition, in accordance with a letter of reprimand in January 2002. Garvey used a police communications community to “speak about white energy” – “one thing that ought to have by no means been said anyplace [and] could possibly be construed as a racist comment by anybody,” a captain wrote.

One week later, Garvey was suspended for 2 days. After pulling over ladies drivers, he didn’t problem tickets or warnings. As an alternative, he slapped their arms – actually, in accordance with a disciplinary letter from a captain. Confronted by supervisors, Garvey admitted “he had achieved this 2 or three occasions,” the captain wrote. “Moments later it went to three to four occasions, and earlier than he left the workplace it was as much as 5 or 6 occasions.”

“I recommend that you simply think about this matter a studying expertise,” the police chief on the time wrote to Garvey.

Six months later, Garvey was reprimanded once more – this time, based on a letter from the police chief, after being accused of “handcuffing a younger woman and placing her into your squad automotive for instance that she wouldn’t need to be arrested.”

In 2001, Garvey was reprimanded for inflicting a crash. “I hope this might be a lesson discovered,” an assistant chief wrote. Garvey was subsequently disciplined for inflicting crashes in 2003, 2006, 2008 and 2011. In 2010 he hit one other automotive on his approach to work, sending the opposite driver to the hospital, in line with a narrative in The Elkhart Fact.

In a single yr alone, 2003, Garvey acquired three suspensions and 5 reprimands.

In 2005, Garvey was reprimanded for failing to seem in courtroom when subpoenaed. “I belief this won’t occur once more sooner or later,” a police captain wrote. Precisely one week later, it occurred once more, and Garvey was suspended.

Elkhart, Indiana, is usually recognized by the nickname the “metropolis with a coronary heart.” (Robert Franklin/South Bend Tribune)


Garvey has been written up repeatedly for failing to maintain his cellular recording system on when answering calls. “This sort of conduct won’t be tolerated,” the police chief wrote in Garvey’s first suspension for this violation. “I discover this inexcusable,” wrote an assistant chief seven years later, when Garvey was suspended a fifth time for a similar misconduct.

One police chief wrote to Garvey: “you don’t take heed to others.”

Garvey’s longest suspension, for 15 days, was issued in 2011; an investigation by one in every of Garvey’s superiors turned up 13 instances during which Garvey’s work as an proof technician was unacceptable or incomplete. “One thing must occur that may right your conduct,” the police chief wrote.

Final yr, Windbigler promoted Garvey to sergeant. By that point Garvey had 11 suspensions, 15 reprimands and one verbal warning.

A reporter lately reviewed Garvey’s personnel historical past with Matthew Hickman, chair of Seattle College’s legal justice division and a former statistician on the U.S. Division of Justice. “He was promoted within the wake of all this?” Hickman stated, scanning the suspensions and reprimands. “That’s very unusual. … I’ve no rationalization for this. … That is weird.”

Hickman is likely one of the few students to have researched police self-discipline. He stated scholarship is scant, as a result of it may be exhausting to get data, and disciplinary methods are a hodgepodge, making comparisons troublesome.

Garvey was reached lately by telephone, at work. “It’s a part of my profession,” he informed a reporter, when requested about his disciplinary document. “I’ve not shied away from any of it, the errors I’ve made. … I’ve discovered from all the things in there.”

Garvey stated he by no means as soon as requested to have a write-up faraway from his file, regardless of how far again. “As a result of I’m a person of integrity,” he stated. “I personal these errors.”

Garvey stated police work is worrying, with numerous alternative to make errors and to make individuals sad: “It’s a noble career. We don’t like idiots, both. Chances are you’ll take a look at my file and say I’m a type of idiots. However I’m not.”

A reporter went by means of Garvey’s file with him. “You understand how a lot time we spend driving as a police officer?” Garvey stated of his automotive crashes. Mix people with know-how, errors will occur, he stated of his failures to document. Missed courtroom dates typically hint to miscommunication with a courtroom clerk, he stated.

Slapping arms? He didn’t do this, Garvey stated. He advised one lady – not six – he was giving her a proverbial slap on the wrist, and the story acquired twisted on its means up the division. White energy? No matter he typed again then on that knowledge terminal, “it wasn’t racial,” Garvey stated. “That’s the furthest factor from who I’m.”

“My profession has rotated,” Garvey stated. For 4 years, he was president of the native Fraternity of Police, elected by his fellow officers, Garvey stated. He’s presently a sergeant within the providers division, repairing every part from air conditioners to video gear. “There’s not a rattling factor damaged that I can’t repair,” he stated.

Jack Oldroyd joined the division in 2002, a yr after Garvey.

One night time in 2006, whereas on patrol close to downtown, Oldroyd observed a lady in a Chevy parked alongside the road. As he drove previous, the lady appeared to slip down within the driver’s seat, Oldroyd would later testify.

Oldroyd requested the lady to step out, however she refused, gripping the steering wheel, based on courtroom data. Oldroyd hit her arm, then opened the door and tried to tug her out. One other officer arrived and pushed from the passenger aspect. Oldroyd tasered the lady. She kicked his leg. He unleashed a canine, which bit her arm and shoulder. The officers then obtained her on the bottom and utilized handcuffs.

Contained in the automotive, Oldroyd discovered what he believed to be crack cocaine, in accordance with courtroom data. The lady was charged with two felonies, together with battery on a police officer, and three misdemeanors. She spent three months in jail earlier than she might publish bail.

A yr and a half after the arrest, all fees have been dropped. A decide dominated that Oldroyd had no authorized foundation for detaining the lady within the first place. Even when she had been making an attempt to keep away from his eye – one thing the lady disputed – that didn’t represent affordable suspicion of a criminal offense, the decide stated.

When the lady was arrested, she was carrying a sock. It held her driver’s license; her Medicaid, food-stamp and ATM playing cards; a key; some change; and get in touch with info for household and buddies.

The subsequent day, a janitor on the Police Division discovered the sock and all it held in a rubbish can.

Oldroyd advised superiors he’d considered handing the gadgets off to a jail officer for safekeeping, however as an alternative simply threw them away.

Oldroyd was charged with conversion, a misdemeanor, and pleaded responsible. In 2007, a decide sentenced him to a yr’s probation and ordered him to pay $359 in fines and courtroom prices.

The Elkhart County Courthouse in Goshen, Indiana. (Robert Franklin/South Bend Tribune)


The police chief demoted Oldroyd and suspended him for 60 days. A letter from the chief to the Public Security Board recommended Oldroyd for displaying regret and cooperating with the interior investigation. “He suggested his actions have been these of being lazy and silly versus deliberately depriving the suspect of the property,” the chief wrote.

At a Board of Public Security assembly in April 2007, one member, based on the minutes, warned that the board “can be watching and there can be no second probability.”

5 years later, in 2012, the police chief suspended Oldroyd for 5 days for his “excessive state of intoxication” and conduct whereas away at coaching.

Oldroyd attended the state K9 workshop, in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, with one other Elkhart officer. One night time, after a visit to a strip bar, they introduced a lady again to a lodge room. Whereas the lady lay bare, Oldroyd “was touching the feminine” as the opposite officer took video, in accordance with an inner affairs report.

Quickly “everyone staying within the lodge, in addition to the opposite officers on the coaching occasion, was conscious of the conduct and actions of each of our officers,” a division official wrote. The report’s subsequent two and a half pages are blacked out, leaving many particulars unclear.

In 2016, Oldroyd was promoted to sergeant throughout Windbigler’s first month as chief. Reached by telephone, Oldroyd advised a reporter that he would ask higher-ups if he might speak about his disciplinary document, however he by no means referred to as again.

‘Much less speaking extra capturing’

Final yr, one night time in June, an Elkhart police sergeant went on Fb and posted a video of a shootout between police in Maryland and an armed theft suspect.

The sergeant, who, by then, had opened hearth in two deadly shootings by Elkhart police, singled out a lady officer who could possibly be heard updating the suspect’s place.

“I don’t assume that woman might have probably talked on the radio extra,” he wrote.

Two different Elkhart officers chimed in. Every of them had additionally fired their weapons in no less than one deadly capturing by police.

“Maintain all visitors and go to battle,” one wrote.

Elkhart police sergeant’s Fb submit


“Yeah much less speaking extra capturing,” wrote the opposite.

The sergeant who began this thread was Daniel Mayer, a former Marine who had joined the division in 2011.

In November 2013, Mayer had been considered one of three officers who shot and killed a 31-year-old man in a stolen pickup. The person was backing towards them, police stated. His mom filed a wrongful-death go well with, which the town settled for $21,000. The Police Division awarded the three officers medals of valor. (5 different officers concerned in deadly shootings acquired medals on the similar ceremony.)

In September 2014, Mayer was certainly one of seven officers who killed a 32-year-old man in an Elkhart condominium complicated, capturing him roughly 20 occasions. Police stated the person, who was needed, had fired at them first.

Mayer was a frequent presence on Fb. In 2015, he posted a meme of Smokey Bear, holding an assault rifle, as an alternative of a shovel. “Solely you possibly can return hearth,” the meme stated. In 2016, he posted a video of an inmate in Wisconsin who punched a corrections officer and was then swarmed and tackled. Mayer wrote of 1 male corrections officer who hung again: “Take a look at Blondie in prime left…scared.”

In December 2017, Mayer and one other officer shot and killed a financial institution theft suspect – Mayer’s third deadly capturing in 4 years.

The officer who wrote “go to battle” within the June 2017 Fb trade was James Ballard, a corporal.

A squad automotive on the scene of a deadly capturing by Elkhart, Indiana, police in December 2017. Police stated two officers fired on a financial institution theft suspect after the person pointed a gun at a motorist. It was the third deadly capturing involving one of many officers, Sgt. Daniel Mayer, in simply over 4 years. The theft suspect was the sixth individual shot and killed by Elkhart police since 2013. (Michael Caterina/South Bend Tribune)


In September 2013, Ballard had been one among three officers concerned within the deadly capturing of a 27-year-old man armed with a handgun. That proved the primary in a string by which Elkhart police shot and killed six individuals in lower than 5 years. In close by South Bend, which has twice the inhabitants, officers shot and killed two individuals throughout the identical span.

The officer who wrote “much less speaking extra capturing” was Drew Neese, who glided by “Bobby Drewski” on Fb and is the mayor’s son.

Like Mayer, Neese was a sergeant. Additionally like Mayer, Neese was one of many officers who opened hearth within the 2014 deadly capturing during which a person was hit roughly 20 occasions.

On Fb, Neese modified his profile image steadily. One time it was an illustration of President Donald Trump, atop a tank, holding what seems to be a .50-caliber sniper rifle. One other time it was Clint Eastwood as Soiled Harry, pointing that well-known .44 Magnum.

In 2010, Neese had shot a canine whereas executing a search warrant. He fired 13 occasions, a assessment board decided. Nobody knew precisely the place all of the bullets hit. At the least two apparently struck a home, in line with a disciplinary letter. Neese started capturing “a lot too early,” when the canine was about 35 ft away, the letter stated. One witness stated the canine didn’t even cost Neese till after the capturing began.

The police chief, in a letter, informed Neese he “might have simply” killed somebody. He reprimanded Neese and ordered him to get remedial coaching on gun security.

Neese was within the information this month, when the Tribune obtained the video of two different Elkhart cops punching a handcuffed man. Neese was the one supervisor within the room when the beating befell. The video exhibits him strolling over because the beating ends and speaking into his radio.

Mayer, Ballard and Neese didn’t reply to interview requests. Days after a reporter requested Mayor Neese about his son’s phrases on social media, the web page for Bobby Drewski was gone from Fb.

Of the seven present supervisors in Elkhart who’ve opened hearth in a deadly capturing, none was disciplined in consequence. However Todd Thayer, the division’s present assistant chief, landed in hassle after one of many shootings, although he didn’t hearth his gun.

After the September 2013 deadly capturing by three officers, Thayer, then a lieutenant, stated one of many three, a pal of his, might “now examine capturing somebody or being concerned in a capturing off his bucket listing,” in response to disciplinary data. Two witnesses additionally reported that Thayer stated he was jealous of his good friend.

Throughout an inner investigation, Thayer acknowledged the “bucket record” remark however stated he was joking. He said that he didn’t keep in mind saying he was jealous. Dealing with a attainable disciplinary listening to, he volunteered to be demoted two full ranks, right down to corporal. He additionally resigned his positions instructing different officers. Thayer had been educating firearms and use of pressure.

‘A superb olive department’

Drew Neese’s father, Tim, a Republican, served within the Indiana Home of Representatives from 2003 by way of 2014. In 2015, he ran for mayor of Elkhart. His platform included decreasing the mayor’s police oversight position.

The Fraternal Order of Police endorsed Neese and contributed $1,900 to his marketing campaign, considered one of his bigger donations.

Neese gained with 64 % of the vote, defeating incumbent Democrat Dick Moore. 9 individuals interviewed to be police chief. They included Windbigler, who had run that very same yr for metropolis council however misplaced within the Republican main. After Windbigler misplaced the council race, his committee, “Residents to Elect Ed Windbigler,” donated $443 to Neese.

In December 2015, Neese introduced that Windbigler was his selection as chief.

“Windbigler stated Neese made it clear that he needs all the metropolis’s officers going house at night time with out second-guessing themselves and the choices they make,” WSBT-TV, an area CBS affiliate, reported on the time. The story quoted Windbigler saying, “The extra an officer is aware of they’re supported from their very own administration – it doesn’t matter what occurs – if that help is there, they’re going to really feel higher about their job.”

Neese, in a current interview, stated he was impressed with Windbigler’s army background, his work as chief investigator for the county prosecutor’s workplace and the very fact he’d climbed his method by way of the Police Division’s ranks. The mayor stated Windbigler’s 1993 suspension and jury verdict within the civil rights trial by no means got here up within the hiring course of.

Windbigler additionally acquired 5 reprimands between 1989 and 2002, in line with a disciplinary abstract sheet launched to the Tribune this week. Three have been for crashes. The summaries for the opposite two say: “As a supervisor, set a poor instance within the significance of a great pat down search”; and “inappropriate conduct displayed in entrance of constituents, set a greater instance for others to comply with.”

Whereas choosing Windbigler as chief, Neese additionally tapped a retired police officer for an additional metropolis job. To run the division that will get referred to as upon in case of flooding, tornadoes or different disasters, Neese appointed John Faigh, who, as a police officer, had been disciplined no less than 20 occasions for incompetence, insubordination and different violations of coverage. As soon as, whereas on obligation as a area supervisor, Faigh had been present in a cemetery, in his squad automotive, “laying throughout the passenger seat, sleeping.”

Neese stated he didn’t know of Faigh’s disciplinary report when he employed him to run the emergency administration division. Faigh didn’t return messages in search of remark. In 2009, when questioned by the general public security board about his disciplinary report, he stated, “In no method have I ever disgraced the Elkhart Police Division, myself, or my credibility.”

Constant together with his marketing campaign pledge, Neese acquired approval from the Elkhart Widespread Council in November 2016 to shift disciplinary authority from the Board of Public Security to a brand new police benefit fee. Windbigler supported the transfer.

Whereas the mayor appointed all 5 members of the Board of Public Security, the benefit fee consists of two members chosen by the Police Division, together with two mayoral appointees and one member chosen by the Widespread Council.

Elkhart Police Division Assistant Chief Todd Thayer seems in October earlier than the town’s Police Benefit Fee, a civilian oversight panel that has authority over the hiring, promotion and self-discipline of officers. The police division’s present management has introduced few disciplinary actions to the fee. (Santiago Flores/South Bend Tribune Photograph)


Neese stated some cops informed him that beneath the Board of Public Security, earlier mayors had rewarded loyalists with promotions, hurting morale.

At a gathering of the town’s Widespread Council, Windbigler asserted that he had seen unfair remedy of police by prior mayors.

“We’ve all been round lengthy sufficient the place we have now seen some vindictiveness come from totally different administrations,” Windbigler advised the council, with out offering any examples. He referred to as the benefit fee a “good olive department to move out” to the Police Division.

The council voted 6-1 in favor of the change.

One of many six, Republican Adam Bujalski, referred to as it one of many “best issues I’m gonna say sure to that we’ve executed all yr,” partly as a result of, for police, the change was “one of many causes they supported (Neese) coming in … as a result of that is one thing he promised them.”

Bujalski famous that police would now “have a say in who’s going to be disciplining them.”

The benefit fee’s president, Jim Rieckhoff, is among the two members chosen by the Police Division. In an interview, Rieckhoff, a former Elkhart Superior Courtroom decide, praised Windbigler as a “man of excessive integrity and honor,” and stated officer morale has improved on his watch. “Individuals are smiling across the office,” Rieckhoff stated. “They appear to be supportive of one another.”

Windbigler has not introduced the fee any instances during which he’s pursuing a suspension exceeding 5 days, the edge requiring fee approval, Rieckhoff stated. The fee’s conferences are sometimes brief. Typically they’re simply canceled. “And I prefer it that approach,” Rieckhoff stated. “It’s a very good factor, within the sense that it implies issues are going properly.”

In 2017, Windbigler introduced 5 disciplinary instances to the fee. This yr, by means of October, he has introduced three – all reprimands, together with these for the 2 officers who have been videotaped beating the handcuffed man.

Elkhart Police Benefit Fee president James Rieckhoff, left, and member Brad Billings throughout a public assembly in October. The Elkhart Police Division’s present management has not introduced ahead a single disciplinary motion requiring the fee’s approval. (Santiago Flores/South Bend Tribune Photograph)


Rieckhoff stated that when signing off on promotions, the fee doesn’t ask about disciplinary histories. A reporter informed Rieckhoff concerning the personnel information that confirmed most supervisors had been disciplined and 15 suspended.

“I had no concept there have been that many,” Rieckhoff stated. “So far as I can inform, they do good work.”

Elkhart Widespread Council member Dwight Fish, a Democrat who represents a district with a big minority inhabitants, forged the lone vote towards creating the Police Benefit Fee. On Nov. 6, he went on Fb to touch upon a Tribune story concerning the two cops who beat a handcuffed man. The story additionally recognized two different officers who had been within the room on the time – Drew Neese, and the president of the native Fraternal Order of Police.

Fish addressed his phrases to the mayor: “Don’t BULLSHIT … Everybody concerned (and watching) on this incident must be reprimanded and self-discipline motion taken. Police Chief Windbigler should work very exhausting to restore the injury to the psyche of the residents. All of the work I’ve been doing to restore and heal the worry on the Southside is now gone due to an aggressive and violent police pressure. Gone right away due to brief tempers and a non-compassionate EPD. I’m ashamed of this metropolis proper now.”

In a current interview, Fish stated any police pressure has examples of misconduct threaded by means of its historical past, however he had by no means seen something “this dramatic and this violent,” and he was “disgusted” with Neese and Windbigler for not doing extra to cope with the January beating.

“My constituents are mad as hell,” he stated. “My constituents are scared as hell.”

After the Tribune and ProPublica revealed video of the beating, Tim Neese stated the Police Division would create a brand new board to assessment makes use of of pressure.

He stated the board can be made up of 5 individuals – and all 5 can be cops, together with an assistant chief, a captain and an inner affairs lieutenant.

Christian Sheckler is a contributor on South Bend Tribune.

Ken Armstrong is a senior reporter at ProPublica.

Earlier articleVermont immigrant rights group sues ICE for monitoring, infiltrating & ‘searching down’ organizers

s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
fbq(‘init’, ‘427173287806805’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);